FremontTroll
New Fish
My understanding from what I read is that if you for example report to your doctor suicidal thoughts, they can involuntarily commit you as a danger to yourself. Otherwise the doctor is afraid of getting sued for doing nothing. Depending on the circumstances, you could wind up being "warehoused" somewhere in a room with 50 motherfuckers all depressed. Like that would help! So it seems a huge problem is that the suicidal might not seek help for fear of involunatry commitment. It is one of those ridiculous things in life people are too stupid to fix for fear of legal repercussions.
Not true at all but thanks for spreading misinformation.
Nobody is involuntarily committed unless they have active suicidal ideation and a plan to follow through. Intrusive suicidal thoughts not that unusual and not sufficient to be hospitalized.
Also the laws are very specific on involuntary commitment as a least restrictive option. Populations I work with generally spend one week or less in the hospital.
Right, well, if you have suicidal thoughts that means suicidal ideation and a plan probably. You're hairsplitting. The problem is, from what I read, is that if you report that you could wind up being warehoused until help is available. I saw this in the news in the last couple of years. So, my point is still a valid one that a person in such a state is going to be held back from self reporting for fear of being involuntarily committed. Spin it all you want but that would be how it plays out.
No, I am not hairsplitting. There is a nuanced but very significant difference between active suicidal intent with a plan (and means) to carry out your intent and a passive wish to die. People can live for years with ever present suicidal wishes or fleeting and intrusive thoughts without any intent or plan.
If you want to get educated there are many places you can go. If you want to rely on your memory of something you saw on the news a few years ago then go wild. You are wrong though. People may and do fear reporting suicidal unfortunately but their fears are not valid.