the return of 5 reasons

I'd take Brady, Rodgers, P. Manning, and probably Rapelisberger over RW but that's it, and Peyton is fading fast and RW is closing in on Rapelisberger's level.

If he had a horrific knee, hip, or general leg injury and lost his speed, then he's probably behind the Romo/Rivers/Ryan class.
Click to expand...

Manning is done. He was horrific today. His postseason woes are only magnified by his decreasing physicality. He simply could not push the ball down the field.

I noticed how he kept overthrowing his receivers during that stretch of 6 incomplete passes where Denver kept trying to go deep. This is because he no longer has the arm to afford touch on his deep ball. He is overthrowing because anything less than 100% and it won't get home or float for an easy pick.

That was the moment I knew he was done. Psychologically this game finished him. Wilson is better today and forever more moving forward.
 
Best regular season QB of all-time... If not for sexy rexy and the dreckfest Bears he would win the "best QB without a ring" in a heartbeat over Marino and others.
 
I'd take Brady, Rodgers, P. Manning, and probably Rapelisberger over RW but that's it, and Peyton is fading fast and RW is closing in on Rapelisberger's level.

If he had a horrific knee, hip, or general leg injury and lost his speed, then he's probably behind the Romo/Rivers/Ryan class.
Click to expand...

Manning is done. He was horrific today. His postseason woes are only magnified by his decreasing physicality. He simply could not push the ball down the field.

I noticed how he kept overthrowing his receivers during that stretch of 6 incomplete passes where Denver kept trying to go deep. This is because he no longer has the arm to afford touch on his deep ball. He is overthrowing because anything less than 100% and it won't get home or float for an easy pick.

That was the moment I knew he was done. Psychologically this game finished him. Wilson is better today and forever more moving forward.
Click to expand...

Agreed.

Great point earlier whoever mentioned Big Ben, I shouldn't have skipped him.

When the 2015 season kicks off here's the rough order of QB's I'd want:

1 Rodgers
2 Brady
3 Luck
4 Ben
5 Wilson
6 Romo
7 Brees
8 Ryan
9 Rivers

32 Peyton's corpse

But I do think you can argue for Russ over 3 and 4, and Brady's going to hit the wall sometime in the next couple of years himself.

It won't be long and it's Rodgers, Luck, Wilson as the top 3 QB's in the league. Wilson may never get recognized at that level, but he'll reach it rather easily.
 
Last edited:
I'd take Brady, Rodgers, P. Manning, and probably Rapelisberger over RW but that's it, and Peyton is fading fast and RW is closing in on Rapelisberger's level.

If he had a horrific knee, hip, or general leg injury and lost his speed, then he's probably behind the Romo/Rivers/Ryan class.
Click to expand...

Manning is done. He was horrific today. His postseason woes are only magnified by his decreasing physicality. He simply could not push the ball down the field.

I noticed how he kept overthrowing his receivers during that stretch of 6 incomplete passes where Denver kept trying to go deep. This is because he no longer has the arm to afford touch on his deep ball. He is overthrowing because anything less than 100% and it won't get home or float for an easy pick.

That was the moment I knew he was done. Psychologically this game finished him. Wilson is better today and forever more moving forward.
Click to expand...

Agreed.

Great point earlier whoever mentioned Big Ben, I shouldn't have skipped him.

When the 2015 season kicks off here's the rough order of QB's I'd want:

1 Rodgers
2 Brady
3 Luck
4 Ben
5 Wilson

But I think you can argue for Russ over 3 and 4, and Brady's going to hit the wall sometime in the next couple of years himself.

It won't be long and it's Rodgers, Luck, Wilson as the top 3 QB's in the league. Wilson may never get recognized at that level, but he'll reach it rather easily.
Click to expand...

Say, 34-17?
 
I'd take Brady, Rodgers, P. Manning, and probably Rapelisberger over RW but that's it, and Peyton is fading fast and RW is closing in on Rapelisberger's level.

If he had a horrific knee, hip, or general leg injury and lost his speed, then he's probably behind the Romo/Rivers/Ryan class.
Click to expand...

Manning is done. He was horrific today. His postseason woes are only magnified by his decreasing physicality. He simply could not push the ball down the field.

I noticed how he kept overthrowing his receivers during that stretch of 6 incomplete passes where Denver kept trying to go deep. This is because he no longer has the arm to afford touch on his deep ball. He is overthrowing because anything less than 100% and it won't get home or float for an easy pick.

That was the moment I knew he was done. Psychologically this game finished him. Wilson is better today and forever more moving forward.
Click to expand...

Agreed.

Great point earlier whoever mentioned Big Ben, I shouldn't have skipped him.

When the 2015 season kicks off here's the rough order of QB's I'd want:

1 Rodgers
2 Brady
3 Luck
4 Ben
5 Wilson
6 Romo
7 Brees
8 Ryan
9 Rivers

32 Peyton's corpse

But do I think you can argue for Russ over 3 and 4, and Brady's going to hit the wall sometime in the next couple of years himself.

It won't be long and it's Rodgers, Luck, Wilson as the top 3 QB's in the league. Wilson may never get recognized at that level, but he'll reach it rather easily.
Click to expand...

Lindley is way too high, and I put Rivers over Ryan and an aging Brees, otherwise concur.
 
I'd take Brady, Rodgers, P. Manning, and probably Rapelisberger over RW but that's it, and Peyton is fading fast and RW is closing in on Rapelisberger's level.

If he had a horrific knee, hip, or general leg injury and lost his speed, then he's probably behind the Romo/Rivers/Ryan class.
Click to expand...

Manning is done. He was horrific today. His postseason woes are only magnified by his decreasing physicality. He simply could not push the ball down the field.

I noticed how he kept overthrowing his receivers during that stretch of 6 incomplete passes where Denver kept trying to go deep. This is because he no longer has the arm to afford touch on his deep ball. He is overthrowing because anything less than 100% and it won't get home or float for an easy pick.

That was the moment I knew he was done. Psychologically this game finished him. Wilson is better today and forever more moving forward.
Click to expand...

Agreed.

Great point earlier whoever mentioned Big Ben, I shouldn't have skipped him.

When the 2015 season kicks off here's the rough order of QB's I'd want:

1 Rodgers
2 Brady
3 Luck
4 Ben
5 Wilson
6 Romo
7 Brees
8 Ryan
9 Rivers

32 Peyton's corpse

But I do think you can argue for Russ over 3 and 4, and Brady's going to hit the wall sometime in the next couple of years himself.

It won't be long and it's Rodgers, Luck, Wilson as the top 3 QB's in the league. Wilson may never get recognized at that level, but he'll reach it rather easily.
Click to expand...

CAL IS WAY TOO GOD DAMN HIGH!
 
"Yep. I was lost at #1. Russell Wilson is a product of his team. He is the perfect product for that team. Take a bottom dweller in the NFL and give them the choice... no one will take Russell Wilson over Aaron Rodgers. So best player on the field? Not even close. Isn't, and never has been, the best player on his own team."

Same old argument about RW.
 
Russell Wilson is possibly the best dual threat QB of all time. If Michael Vick was ever as good as Russell is, people would think he was the best QB in the league.
 
Better than young? Not sure about that
Click to expand...

Steve Young sucked his first several years in the league. Then couldn't win the big one when he took over for Joe
 
Better than young? Not sure about that
Click to expand...

Young suffers from Edgar Martinez disease. Not starting a full season until his 7th year in the league and 8th year out of BYU seriously limited his career achievements. He also gets the Jerry Rice asterisk.

Baring injury, Wilson should outdo Young's career rather easily.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top