Say Who Hypothetical

No shit. I don't blame the kids for trying to polish a turd like Judd. It's pretty much what they have known
 
No shit. I don't blame the kids for trying to polish a turd like Judd. It's pretty much what they have known
I don’t agree with everything you have to say about Ol’ Judd but at least I’m having a good laff
 
If DeBoer stays last year he wins 6-9 games, let's say 8. Only a middle or upper-middle SEC team would come calling and off the top of my head I don't even know if anybody got fired this year. So there's no LSU, no Florida, etc to try and lure him.
He would probably be at UW 4-5 years while still wanting out of the PNW so I can't see how that situation would be better for UW. We would assuredly be out of the national conversation, if his recruiting at Washington is any indication. His recruits that have transferred out aren't going to the Power 2 and even dropping down to MWC in some cases.
At some point, whether with Grubb or DeBoer or Fisch, you have to address needing to stack talent again in a way that got you to where you were in 2023, 2022, and yes even 2021 where you had the personnel to win the conference.
stack talent.
 
Last year's team is way different if DeBoer stays
Sorry but this retarded because Fisch isn't in the same area code
4-8 to 11-2. DeBoer would have reloaded
First, last week I was told we? don’t deal in hypotheticals here.
No shit, had DeBoer stayed last year we are better considering he took a few starters with him along with a mass exodus from a handful of players that very well could have bolted for cash being on the award winning OL from 2023 to Ole Miss/sec had DeBoer stayed. Like their previous coach, a number of players cashed in on their last year of eligibility in 2024 and 2023’s success.
And don’t pretend that the 4-8 team, most of whom were recruited and early developed by Petersen didn’t play a part in the 26-3 run the two years after the Lake debocal.
I haven’t seen anyone here claim Fisch is a better HC than our previous guy, unless I’m mistaken. DeBoer had a ton of continuity in his staff and it’s very fortunate he was Penix’s former OC when he took the UW job and struck lightening in a bottle. Westover, Culp, the entire OL except Center, including Jalen M and Rome a generational wr at UW. I’m skipping Special Teams and the D.
I wasn’t thrilled with a few decisions Fisch had as a play caller in year one but he seems to be a better recruiter and I still have a glass half full attitude since he turned around Arizona from 1 win in year one to 2 losses in year 4. He’s got work to do obviously, that’s why he’s getting the big bucks I suppose. UW has proved to do much worse in their history of hires since Don. BeBoer and Petersen were fantastic hires and it took 20+ years to get it right after Coach James resigned.
 
Last edited:
There's an interesting hypothetical on the last Say Who pod that I hadn't thought about. Would it have been worse had DeBoer stayed for a third year and then left? I think so, but I also don't think he would've had a good enough season in 2024 to get an offer from something that's much better than a lateral move.
Long story short, I like the direction of Fisch's high school and portal recruiting a bit more than DeBoer's and I feel like if he was going to leave it was better to just rip the band aid off.
JFC you doog idiots.
 
If DeBoer stays last year he wins 6-9 games, let's say 8. Only a middle or upper-middle SEC team would come calling and off the top of my head I don't even know if anybody got fired this year. So there's no LSU, no Florida, etc to try and lure him.
He would probably be at UW 4-5 years while still wanting out of the PNW so I can't see how that situation would be better for UW. We would assuredly be out of the national conversation, if his recruiting at Washington is any indication. His recruits that have transferred out aren't going to the Power 2 and even dropping down to MWC in some cases.
At some point, whether with Grubb or DeBoer or Fisch, you have to address needing to stack talent again in a way that got you to where you were in 2023, 2022, and yes even 2021 where you had the personnel to win the conference.
Impossible to say, because of the mass exodus that occurred after he left two days after our natty game
 
If DeBoer stays last year he wins 6-9 games, let's say 8. Only a middle or upper-middle SEC team would come calling and off the top of my head I don't even know if anybody got fired this year. So there's no LSU, no Florida, etc to try and lure him.
He would probably be at UW 4-5 years while still wanting out of the PNW so I can't see how that situation would be better for UW. We would assuredly be out of the national conversation, if his recruiting at Washington is any indication. His recruits that have transferred out aren't going to the Power 2 and even dropping down to MWC in some cases.
At some point, whether with Grubb or DeBoer or Fisch, you have to address needing to stack talent again in a way that got you to where you were in 2023, 2022, and yes even 2021 where you had the personnel to win the conference.
Impossible to say, because of the mass exodus that occurred after he left two days after our natty game
Kalepo and Buelow were gone man. It's all speculative as to why but they weren't coming back. The Parker twins was their main find at DL and they were supposed to be the guys anchoring the defense. You'd have to argue that they could've gotten one of the medically retired guys to stick it out one more year which didn't seem likely.
Again, the December transfer portal is done. He'd have to somehow hustle and flip guys just because he made a title run, which I don't see that happening in practice. Isn't Notre Dame actually losing starters to fucking Indiana?
I'm not saying DeBoer isn't an elite coach but like it or not you have to stack talent and he hadn't been doing that and was in for a season that was assuredly going to be worse than 2022. Cuevas and Bernard weren't getting us to 10 wins, I'm sorry but I don't see it in any situation and yes that is partly on DeBoer and the fact that his only connections as a head coach were Fresno area high schools and players.
I'm LIPO on Jedd but the 2 things we really need right now (stacking talent and a star quarterback) appear to be happening so I don't care about an expansion season where we flipped a coin in a shitty bowl to go 6-7 instead of 7-6. Like half of Petersen's years were this shitty and he didn't have any decent wins in those years besides #25 USC on the road.
 
Be not like the pebble, but the leaf. CFB is conspiring against us to ruin the sport. All we can do is go along with it.
On the flipside @YellowSnow I saw Pantera the other night, and I have to say they did a great job (it is not clear to me if you hate them or not…). I was transported back to college. I guess if your guitar player gets shot 20 years ago the setlist can't have any new album tracks to promote. It was good.
 
Be not like the pebble, but the leaf. CFB is conspiring against us to ruin the sport. All we can do is go along with it.
On the flipside @YellowSnow I saw Pantera the other night, and I have to say they did a great job (it is not clear to me if you hate them or not…). I was transported back to college. I guess if your guitar player gets shot 20 years ago the setlist can't have any new album tracks to promote. It was good.
I saw Pantera open up for OG Black Sabbath at Key Arena in 1997. Wasn't a fan.
 
Be not like the pebble, but the leaf. CFB is conspiring against us to ruin the sport. All we can do is go along with it.
On the flipside @YellowSnow I saw Pantera the other night, and I have to say they did a great job (it is not clear to me if you hate them or not…). I was transported back to college. I guess if your guitar player gets shot 20 years ago the setlist can't have any new album tracks to promote. It was good.
@ukdawg has it figured out regarding Uni sports. There's basically only one- i.e., row boat. I've been to the Oxford vs Cambridge boat race and it was spectacular.
If you wanna be a professional soccer ball player, you sign a contract out of High School (or whatever the limeys call it) and go pro. You don't have the opportunity to play professionally for Cambridge.
This is the way. Fuck the kids and blow up college sports.
 
Last edited:
Long opinion short I don't think DeBoer was ever staying long unless it was a situation where he wasn't winning enough to even take a slightly above lateral SEC job. I think they're slightly better in 2024 if he stays, but maybe not at all. Also remember he wasn't bringing in a playmaker at RB and I agree that I think glue guys like Kalepo, Hatchett, possibly Buelow, Muhammad, and Powell were still leaving. The portal guys he brought in were exceptionally underwhelming and most of his recruits have been phantoms (Bernard and Brailsford annoyingly were Jimmy guys).
Long term I would have kept DeBoer but given I don't think that was a reality I think it was better he left after 2023 than 2024.
 
There's an interesting hypothetical on the last Say Who pod that I hadn't thought about. Would it have been worse had DeBoer stayed for a third year and then left? I think so, but I also don't think he would've had a good enough season in 2024 to get an offer from something that's much better than a lateral move.
Long story short, I like the direction of Fisch's high school and portal recruiting a bit more than DeBoer's and I feel like if he was going to leave it was better to just rip the band aid off.
JFC you doog idiots.
Dude, is our high school recruiting not sick? Is the defense not totally stacked for next season? How sick do we need to be to be SICK for 2024? Do we still need to go blow a pro sports own to be totally sick?
 
Be not like the pebble, but the leaf. CFB is conspiring against us to ruin the sport. All we can do is go along with it.
On the flipside @YellowSnow I saw Pantera the other night, and I have to say they did a great job (it is not clear to me if you hate them or not…). I was transported back to college. I guess if your guitar player gets shot 20 years ago the setlist can't have any new album tracks to promote. It was good.
My gf and I have a deal. For every minute she makes me have to hear the dud that is some show called Abbott Elementary I make her listen to Pantera. My gf is unaware of this agreement.
 
There's an interesting hypothetical on the last Say Who pod that I hadn't thought about. Would it have been worse had DeBoer stayed for a third year and then left? I think so, but I also don't think he would've had a good enough season in 2024 to get an offer from something that's much better than a lateral move.
Long story short, I like the direction of Fisch's high school and portal recruiting a bit more than DeBoer's and I feel like if he was going to leave it was better to just rip the band aid off.
JFC you doog idiots.
Good to see it's time for internet access hours at the Woodburn Juvenile Hall.
 
There's an interesting hypothetical on the last Say Who pod that I hadn't thought about. Would it have been worse had DeBoer stayed for a third year and then left? I think so, but I also don't think he would've had a good enough season in 2024 to get an offer from something that's much better than a lateral move.
Long story short, I like the direction of Fisch's high school and portal recruiting a bit more than DeBoer's and I feel like if he was going to leave it was better to just rip the band aid off.
JFC you doog idiots.
As opposed to offseason hot talk about what? Jerking off to Lannings Bond villain facial hair?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top