The board should realize that Huard's first game as a freshman is better than any game Sirmon has had. I'm not even kidding.
Stars are important, but a guy like Sirmon is an example why these ratings can be shit.
If the "experts" are on a prospect's jock when they are 15, they won't drop them to embarrassing levels. These are still kids.
Dublanko is an example. He was shit. He was rightfully dropped, but was still rated embarrassingly high. He had no real offers and he was still rated higher than Tryon.
Darrell Daniels went from the #3 WR to being a 4 star.
If Pete dropped Sirmon, he might be able to catch on with a shitty BCS team. I have no way of really knowing this, but he's not nearly thought of to college coaches like he is to the rankings.
In Yankoff We Trust.