I looked at the games you have played and will finish with and it looks as bad as Arizona. It is very weak and in the two tests the Dawgs have had you failed, so you still do not know now if this team is any good? That is why ten wins is wow. Everyone thinks UCLA is easy, don't count on it. Apple Cup is a toss up being a rivalry game. Going to Tucson is like this week on the road, tough. For ASU it is the other team that choked, schemed bad, or just did not perform. It's like the Devil's wins against USC and Stanford are meaningless, just luck with a bad defense. I got this in the podcast and from the media on the USC game, but decent teams put average teams away. Stanford and Washington are alike in style and ASU will play the same defensive formation and beating the Trees gives confidence.
Every game is different because its a different matchup. Your defense had one good game against one of the weaker offenses, at home with two weeks to prepare. People were saying how would we stop Cal and we held them to 7 with Danny Shelton and Shaq out that entire drive. Then people thought we could matchup well with Oregon's offense. Every game is going to be different. Oregon loses a few OL and they can't run for shit on a small Arizona defense. They beat MSU by 19 then barely beat WSU. You guys get plungered by UCLA then both go in opposite directions. Its match ups, circumstances and little things. Just because we plungered Cal and Arizona needed a hail mary, does that mean we will handily beat Arizona? No. The circumstances last year for UW going to ASU were terrible and we noted that on last years podcast, all picking ASU to win.
I did do research on the OL. Its a lot better but Douglas is really the only stalwart. We got a few sacks last week and that was with 2 AA type guys Grassu and Fisher lined up against Shelton and Kikaha. You gave up four sacks last week. Whoever the QB is, he will be facing lots of pressure. The key for UW will probably be the LB's who were terrible against UO but great against Cal and good against Stanford. At home, odds are they play well.
If we scored 13 at home at Stanford and 20 against Oregon, its reasonable to think we can score 24-27 against ASU at home. I'd say there is a strong likelihood of scoring 17-27.
You scored 26 against Stanford at home, 10pts aided by turnovers. UW doesn't have as good of a defense but UW does have a better DL and ASU will be playing on the road in a nasty environment, coming off back to back emotional highs. If UW doesn't make any mistakes then they can hold ASU under 24 points. Regarding USC, their defense gets really tired at the end of games. They are really struggling on defense at the end of games.
Now if UW's offense is a dreckfest and ASU's offense doesn't give it away then I could see a 24-14 or 27-17, 26-20 type ASU win.
Regarding the metrics, the pure SRS actually defeats my personal disdain for ASU. They are only 2 spots behind UW. Its championships and major bowl wins where ASU is far behind.
I don't see the objection about 10 wins. We are including a bowl game. So 10-4. We all kind of agreed that 9-4 is realistic or reasonable. Thats beating Colorado, OSU, WSU and taking only 1 of 3 from ASU, UA and UCLA. WSU will be tough but we should have the front 7 to pressure their passing game quite a bit as we did with Cal. If UW had a typical schedule this year we'd be looking at 8 wins. The Hawaii game and easier conference schedule probably adds close to 2 wins. We lose a ton on defense so 2015 is definitely a rebuilding year for us. Unless we finish this year on a roll I'd be thrilled with a top 30 metrics finish next year.
Graham has done an excellent job rebuilding and Petersens rebuild probably won't be as fast. ASU was almost top 25 SRS in 2012 and was #7 last year. They are around 25-30 now in the metrics and have a good chance to finish in the top 20. Thats really outstanding considering the starters lost from last years squad. Also, ASU has not had back to back +500 conference seasons since 96-97. Graham did that his first two years and this looks to be three which has not happened since 80-82. He's done very well so far. The question is if he can make a playoff and how long will he be there. The south is more difficult as you are dealing with USC, UCLA and Arizona. Utah is a pain in the ass some years. Arizona has a lot of talent and both schools need to dominate that state.