Has Troy Williams been named the starter yet?

[HFNY]

Actually yes, please list the comparisons that Lindquist and Miles drew as I'd love to hear them. And no shit that Browning is still in high school...but he's going to be here in the spring and is actually moving up in the recruiting rankings during his senior year which is a positive (vs. someone like Nick Montana LOSING his 4th star, which doesn't happen often). Since Browning committed so early, there's less SIZZLE about him but everything is indicating that he will be a good one.

But I agree with you about people being stupid in talking about TW. Hell, he picked UW over Gus Malzahn at Auburn and I think the world of Malzahn's coaching and scouting abilities. His H.S. scouting reports were also more positive than Miles' and noted his leadership skills.

And while Oregon was rotating some guys in on D, they largely kept their starters in on both sides of the ball because they felt they needed style points with 1 loss already. For instance Mariota played every series even though they were up by 3 scores and in the picture of Williams getting into the end-zone on his good TD run, one can see Oregon's starting safety in the background (Reggie Daniels). Regardless, it was encouraging that Williams didn't press and try to force the ball into coverage to try to look good but instead took what the defense gave him.

Great post except that Browning should be a good one. Apparently he's unbelievably accurate and pretty mobile. I've heard Aaron Murray as a comparison.

Williams oozes potential and he's more mobile than Miles which will helps the running game (keeping the D honest on the zone-read), helps 3rd down conversions (because he can more easily run for a 1st down if no one is open), and helps an OL that doesn't give the QB enough time.

If we keep starting Miles, teams are going to continue to focus on shutting down our running game and making him beat them with his arm and legs. It's pretty clear now that Miles won't be able to do that against the better teams in the conference and probably won't work against ASU / Todd Graham either.

Would you like me to list the comparisons that Lindquist, Miles, Williams and KJCS drew as well?

Who gives a fucking shit about Browning? He's just a kid in HS. TBS doogy-ness. Jesus.

Also, the argument that @uzi‌ is using about Troy Williams being mediocre is stupid. Did Peenerman say he didn't pick him because he was mediocre? No. Too high variance in performance (calling @Tequilla) sure, but that's not the same fucking thing as mediocre.

I can't believe how fucktarded everyone got around here in 48 hours.

Christ!

FMFYFE.

 

[HFNY]

One thing I respect about Graham is that he's like a shark who smells weakness and period blood in the water and then gets after it.

Do you think Kelly comes back this game or sits another week. Does it matter? I thought ASU's D was pretty good last year but is it rebuilding this year?

On O, how is your OL and how much does the O miss Marion Grice?

If Miles starts it's going to be tough for you because Graham will blitz like there's no tomorrow. I don't thuink Miles can handle that.

 

[RoadDawg55]

Browning looks like a great get, but counting on him to come in as a freshman and start is probably a stretch. It just doesn't happen very often. Who was the last true freshman QB in the Pac 12 that actually played well? Goff played for Cal last year, but mostly struggled on a shitty team. Barkley was okay for USC, but he had a lot of talent and help around him.

At one point Miles, Williams, Lindquist, and Carta-Samuels (to a lesser extent) were all highly regarded prospects with big time schools after them. Browning is also pretty slight at 185. He may not be physically ready either. There is a lot to still play out. History says he won't start. I'd put it well over 50% that he redshirts, learns the system, and gets ready physically before they throw him out there. The last thing you want to do is throw him out there, he's not ready, his confidence takes a hit, or he gets hurt.

 

[HFNY]

Oh I'm certainly not saying I expect him to start as a true frosh and fully expect him to redshirt. BUT, that doesn't mean people shouldn't look forward to getting him on the roster and getting coached up.

My crystal balls certainly failed me this past Saturday but they aren't shattered yet and they are telling me that Troy Williams or KJCS will be the starter in 2015 and Miles will transfer after the season.

 

[HFNY]

Miles ran the ball 6 times for just 13 yards (and took 2 sacks for -18 yards) and had two very costly turnovers (a terrible throw that was high and behind the WR and an unforced fumble that he dropped on his own). 2 TOs against an average to slightly above average D and averaging 2.2 ypc isn't exactly stellar.

So Williams averaging 5.6 ypc, running for a TD, and not turning the ball over in 15 times throwing or running should be important. Since Oregon lost to Arizona, they wanted style points which is why Mariota played the whole game and Oregon still was playing some of their first team D against Williams (while Williams had our 3rd string RB at his disposal and we saw more of the two true frosh WRs when he was in).

Williams hit the rb out of the back field a few times vs soft coverage and scrambled a few times. BFd. He may also be a turnover machine waiting to happen. Who knows.

Either way if our safeties still take shitty angles and can't tackle and we can't run the ball asu is going to sodomize us on our home field.

Eod

 

[RoadDawg55]

LIPO. It's perfectly logical to want Williams to play after Miles' struggles, but the garbage time didn't mean shit. AtomicDawg is right. Oregon may have wanted style points, but it's hard to keep the same intensity up 29 points.

A lot of this is searching because we are unhappy with Miles' play. Nobody has a clue if Williams is any good.

Miles ran the ball 6 times for just 13 yards (and took 2 sacks for -18 yards) and had two very costly turnovers (a terrible throw that was high and behind the WR and an unforced fumble that he dropped on his own). 2 TOs against an average to slightly above average D and averaging 2.2 ypc isn't exactly stellar.

So Williams averaging 5.6 ypc, running for a TD, and not turning the ball over in 15 times throwing or running should be important. Since Oregon lost to Arizona, they wanted style points which is why Mariota played the whole game and Oregon still was playing some of their first team D against Williams (while Williams had our 3rd string RB at his disposal and we saw more of the two true frosh WRs when he was in).

Williams hit the rb out of the back field a few times vs soft coverage and scrambled a few times. BFd. He may also be a turnover machine waiting to happen. Who knows.

Either way if our safeties still take shitty angles and can't tackle and we can't run the ball asu is going to sodomize us on our home field.

Eod

 

[claycha]

NM. FM!

 

[HFNY]

I see what you're saying but trust me, Williams has the highest ceiling out of the 3 QBs who have played this year. I've heard that from people within the program and saw it with my own eyes on Saturday.

If Miles is healthy, I'm pretty sure Petersen will start him and give him at least another half of football against ASU to give him a chance to prove himself against another Pac-12 D that isn't Cal (or Colorado / WSU). If he struggles again, I'd like to see Williams after the half because Graham is going to load the box and dare Miles to beat him with quick and accurate passes against his blitzes.

LIPO. It's perfectly logical to want Williams to play after Miles' struggles, but the garbage time didn't mean shit. AtomicDawg is right. Oregon may have wanted style points, but it's hard to keep the same intensity up 29 points.

A lot of this is searching because we are unhappy with Miles' play. Nobody has a clue if Williams is any good.

Miles ran the ball 6 times for just 13 yards (and took 2 sacks for -18 yards) and had two very costly turnovers (a terrible throw that was high and behind the WR and an unforced fumble that he dropped on his own). 2 TOs against an average to slightly above average D and averaging 2.2 ypc isn't exactly stellar.

So Williams averaging 5.6 ypc, running for a TD, and not turning the ball over in 15 times throwing or running should be important. Since Oregon lost to Arizona, they wanted style points which is why Mariota played the whole game and Oregon still was playing some of their first team D against Williams (while Williams had our 3rd string RB at his disposal and we saw more of the two true frosh WRs when he was in).

Williams hit the rb out of the back field a few times vs soft coverage and scrambled a few times. BFd. He may also be a turnover machine waiting to happen. Who knows.

Either way if our safeties still take shitty angles and can't tackle and we can't run the ball asu is going to sodomize us on our home field.

Eod

 

[TheHB]

Miles, Williams, Lindquist ... it doesn't fucking matter who the hell starts. The offensive line can't block for shit and there is no Sankey in the backfield. The Cactus Bowl looks pretty good right now.

 

[AtomicDawg]

Miles, Williams, Lindquist ... it doesn't fucking matter who the hell starts. The offensive line can't block for shit and there is no Sankey in the backfield. The Cactus Bowl looks pretty good right now.

EOD

 

[HeretoBeatmyChest]

Miles, Williams, Lindquist ... it doesn't fucking matter who the hell starts. The offensive line can't block for shit and there is no Sankey in the backfield. The Cactus Bowl looks pretty good right now.

Actually the OL gave Miles plenty of time. The OL is not the problem. We've been used to having good skill guys and a bad line. Now we have no skill guys but a decent line. ASJ, Sankey, Smith, healthy Kasen, String….too much talent lost in one offseason.

 

[dhdawg]

Miles, Williams, Lindquist ... it doesn't fucking matter who the hell starts. The offensive line can't block for shit and there is no Sankey in the backfield. The Cactus Bowl looks pretty good right now.

Actually the OL gave Miles plenty of time. The OL is not the problem. We've been used to having good skill guys and a bad line. Now we have no skill guys but a decent line. ASJ, Sankey, Smith, healthy Kasen, String….too much talent lost in one offseason.

I don't watch all 22 or any shot like that, but from what I've seen pass blocking has been good and run blocking has been subpart.
Perhaps the quality or lack thereof of our RB's is making the Oline look worse than it actually is though

 

[doogsinparadise]

The oline sucks, and was massively overrated coming into the year nuff said on that. Were you not watching the same Oregon players stuff plays in the backfield all game long?

 

[Swaye]

Miles, Williams, Lindquist ... it doesn't fucking matter who the hell starts. The offensive line can't block for shit and there is no Sankey in the backfield. The Cactus Ebola Bowl looks pretty good right now.

 

[pawz]

Miles, Williams, Lindquist ... it doesn't fucking matter who the hell starts. The offensive line can't block for shit and there is no Sankey in the backfield. The Cactus Bowl Plunger Rape Bowellooks pretty good right now.

Fixed for accuracy.

 

[FreeChavez]

Here's what we have with miles.

To the positive - Every once in a while I feel like he's making progress in one series, only to have 4 series in a row where he sucks. I start to wonder if i'm celebrating a good throw as if it's my 2yr old pooping in the potty instead of his inspector gadget skivies, is that really the bar we want to be at for a UW QB?

His WR's continually drop balls even when he finally makes a good read and gets the ball there.

He hasn't had a whole lot of turn overs this season. Yes, i know the oregon pick was brutal but I can also argue that that game could have been light years different had mickens made the catch that went through his hands for a TD early on and our LB's made 1 tackle. That throw was one of the logs in the toilet where i rejoiced for cycler's execution.

To the negative - We have a guy who continually can not make adjustments at the line, read defenses, or throw the ball down field by staying in the pocket long enough to actually make reads(much of this is done presnap btw).

Our OL isn't insanely good by any means, but people piling on the OL acting as if it's their job to block for 4 or 5 seconds are nuts. Cyler does a horrid job of reading defenses pre-snap, which means his progression takes longer, and then he has trouble actually pulling the trigger(whether by confidence or horrid mechanics and a noodle arm).

He has vapor lock on one WR, which has to put the defense in an even better position. I haven't watched a qb in a long time with such a lock on a WR who isn't an elite stud. I get if he had reggie williams out there, but mickens isn't exactly on par with that class of WR. As soon as mickens isn't open, we dump it off.

At the end of the day it almost feels like Peterman is trying to reward cyler for working so hard after his screwup, and doesn't want to give someone else a shot who may actually take this offense to another level because it's an unknown.

I just expect more than to be excited when the QB actually makes a division 1 throw and feel a bit giddy inside. Maybe I should get him M'&M's Co-eds like my son and we can see if the reward system for pooping can work with legitimate throws.

 

[FreeChavez]

Browning looks like a great get, but counting on him to come in as a freshman and start is probably a stretch. It just doesn't happen very often. Who was the last true freshman QB in the Pac 12 that actually played well? Goff played for Cal last year, but mostly struggled on a shitty team. Barkley was okay for USC, but he had a lot of talent and help around him.

At one point Miles, Williams, Lindquist, and Carta-Samuels (to a lesser extent) were all highly regarded prospects with big time schools after them. Browning is also pretty slight at 185. He may not be physically ready either. There is a lot to still play out. History says he won't start. I'd put it well over 50% that he redshirts, learns the system, and gets ready physically before they throw him out there. The last thing you want to do is throw him out there, he's not ready, his confidence takes a hit, or he gets hurt.

Very doubtful a frosh comes in and is in a place to win the job even with spring practice. It's a huge task. The more i've seen with this crop of QB's though, makes it seem like it's possible. Miles reads defenses, blitzes and scrambles out of the pocket like a frosh. I don't see how browning would be much worse. The only thing that may change in your head is that cycler has rs soph next to his name instead of true frosh.

I hope that with this year and offseason that one of the guys on our roster steps up to take the job. I don't care who it is, but I've obviously seen more than enough from what cyler brings to this team. I'd like to see one of the other guys who can actually be a threat to the defense take the reigns. We certainly know spring ball is going to be crazy with Cyler, Lindy, Troy, KS and browning in. I fully expect if troy/KS/Browning win the job that cyler is gone(he may be gone this year if he loses the job before years end).

 

[RoadDawg55]

Miles, Williams, Lindquist ... it doesn't fucking matter who the hell starts. The offensive line can't block for shit and there is no Sankey in the backfield. The Cactus Bowl looks pretty good right now.

Actually the OL gave Miles plenty of time. The OL is not the problem. We've been used to having good skill guys and a bad line. Now we have no skill guys but a decent line. ASJ, Sankey, Smith, healthy Kasen, String….too much talent lost in one offseason.

They aren't a strength and considering they have 3 seniors and a junior who has started since he was a freshman, they suck. They did give Miles time against Oregon though. The RB's never break any tackles in the second level when they do open holes. They would look better with a better QB and RB's, but they have been a disappointment this season, especially in the running game.

 

[thechatch]

I had already turned the game off in disgust. Was Williams really that much different?

Oregon had their scrubs in playing a Cover 2 under with a 3-man rush. He did what any excited kid would do, he played way harder than anyone else out there because no one gave a fuck but him.

As someone who has been a QB coach for a very long time now this is the hope you get when your starter is struggling but it hardly ever turns into a reality.

Being honest, just give Peterman three or four years to get his team together. Look at any coach that wasn't Chip Kelly. It takes awhile to turn shit into shinola.

Finally someone gets it. Omg Cyler sucks! Play his backup Peterman!!!1!!!!!11

Christ. If Williams were better than Miles, he'd start over Miles.

 

[HFNY]

Pressing.

Unless it's a smoke screen (since ASU isn't Cal and Graham isn't Dykes), it's pretty clear that Peterson thinks Miles has the highest floor and gives the team the best opportunity to win right now ....BUT he just may be positioning himself to pull the plug on the Miley Cyrus experiment after the first half if ASU's D gets all up in him.

I had already turned the game off in disgust. Was Williams really that much different?

Oregon had their scrubs in playing a Cover 2 under with a 3-man rush. He did what any excited kid would do, he played way harder than anyone else out there because no one gave a fuck but him.

As someone who has been a QB coach for a very long time now this is the hope you get when your starter is struggling but it hardly ever turns into a reality.

Being honest, just give Peterman three or four years to get his team together. Look at any coach that wasn't Chip Kelly. It takes awhile to turn shit into shinola.

Finally someone gets it. Omg Cyler sucks! Play his backup Peterman!!!1!!!!!11

Christ. If Williams were better than Miles, he'd start over Miles.