Greatest 9th Album in Rock Music History?

[YellowSnow]

Tough between Pet Sounds and Floyd. PS is more influential, but WYWH is my sentimental favorite Floyd album

So I'm hearing vanilla is better after all

Vote ya pussy

I'm getting there - I've eliminated Pet Sounds

@Mad_Son doesn’t take these shit poles lightly.

 

[Mad_Son]

Tough between Pet Sounds and Floyd. PS is more influential, but WYWH is my sentimental favorite Floyd album

So I'm hearing vanilla is better after all

Vote ya pussy

I'm getting there - I've eliminated Pet Sounds

@Mad_Son doesn’t take these shit poles lightly.

Shit poles are are serious bidness. What if my vote changes the overall outcome? Every vote counts!

 

[BennyBeaver]

Tough between Pet Sounds and Floyd. PS is more influential, but WYWH is my sentimental favorite Floyd album

So I'm hearing vanilla is better after all

Vote ya pussy

I'm getting there - I've eliminated Pet Sounds

@Mad_Son doesn’t take these shit poles lightly.

Shit poles are are serious bidness. What if my vote changes the overall outcome? Every vote counts!

TYFYS

 

[chuck]

Tough between Pet Sounds and Floyd. PS is more influential, but WYWH is my sentimental favorite Floyd album

So I'm hearing vanilla is better after all

Vote ya pussy

I'm getting there - I've eliminated Pet Sounds

@Mad_Son doesn’t take these shit poles lightly.

Shit poles are are serious bidness. What if my vote changes the overall outcome? Every vote counts!

 

[PurpleJ]

 

[Pitchfork51]

Tough between Pet Sounds and Floyd. PS is more influential, but WYWH is my sentimental favorite Floyd album

So I'm hearing vanilla is better after all

Vote ya pussy

I'm getting there - I've eliminated Pet Sounds

@Mad_Son doesn’t take these shit poles lightly.

Shit poles are are serious bidness. What if my vote changes the overall outcome? Every vote counts!

Thats what I thought up until a year ago

When @Swaye was caught red-handed (lulz) tampering with the outcome.

Collusion on a level never before seen

 

[Swaye]

Tough between Pet Sounds and Floyd. PS is more influential, but WYWH is my sentimental favorite Floyd album

So I'm hearing vanilla is better after all

Vote ya pussy

I'm getting there - I've eliminated Pet Sounds

@Mad_Son doesn’t take these shit poles lightly.

Shit poles are are serious bidness. What if my vote changes the overall outcome? Every vote counts!

Thats what I thought up until a year ago

When @Swaye was caught red-handed (lulz) tampering with the outcome.

Collusion on a level never before seen

Please do not appoint HarldyClothed to chinvestigate me.

 

[YellowSnow]

View attachment 19883

IFL Coda. Not a REAL album.

 

[89ute]

My power rankings of this round....

1- Sticky Fingers
2- Pet Sounds
3- Nashville Skyline
4- Wish You Were Here

I love the top end songs of Pet Sounds so much and it was probably more influential than any record on this list. But Sticky Finger is epic from front to the back and has 2 of my top 10 songs of all time- i.e., Dead Flowers and Can't You Hear Me Knocking.

Made the decision to count MMT as a Beatle's album even though it was really just an EP in the UK + stray singles from 1967. It was a proper LP in the US and was all new material for that year.

I get flustered every time I try to rank Stones songs. I just can't. Best I can do on this album would be to put "Bitch" toward the bottom, even though it's a great song. Moonlight Mile, in my opinion is a greatly underrated track. It just flows right through you. The two you mentioned are off the charts of course. Christ, when it comes to this band, you just don't need anything else. Let me be with my Stones albums and the world can just go fuck off.

 

[YellowSnow]

My power rankings of this round....

1- Sticky Fingers
2- Pet Sounds
3- Nashville Skyline
4- Wish You Were Here

I love the top end songs of Pet Sounds so much and it was probably more influential than any record on this list. But Sticky Finger is epic from front to the back and has 2 of my top 10 songs of all time- i.e., Dead Flowers and Can't You Hear Me Knocking.

Made the decision to count MMT as a Beatle's album even though it was really just an EP in the UK + stray singles from 1967. It was a proper LP in the US and was all new material for that year.

I get flustered every time I try to rank Stones songs. I just can't. Best I can do on this album would be to put "Bitch" toward the bottom, even though it's a great song. Moonlight Mile, in my opinion is a greatly underrated track. It just flows right through you. The two you mentioned are off the charts of course. Christ, when it comes to this band, you just don't need anything else. Let me be with my Stones albums and the world can just go fuck off.

Run less. Poast mor.

 

[Doogles]

 

[Pitchfork51]

Tough between Pet Sounds and Floyd. PS is more influential, but WYWH is my sentimental favorite Floyd album

So I'm hearing vanilla is better after all

Vote ya pussy

I'm getting there - I've eliminated Pet Sounds

@Mad_Son doesn’t take these shit poles lightly.

Shit poles are are serious bidness. What if my vote changes the overall outcome? Every vote counts!

Thats what I thought up until a year ago

When @Swaye was caught red-handed (lulz) tampering with the outcome.

Collusion on a level never before seen

Please do not appoint HarldyClothed to chinvestigate me.

Lol what pole was it

You recruited spirit horse to tip the scales in your favor