They whiffed on the top ten in state prospects. That is continuing a poor trend started by his predecessor. Not even Sark did that and he DNGAF about Washington State. After Croswell and Robertson this class will have to rely on evaluation and development. No one knows if Herm is good at either. Anyone know how his draft history in the NFL was? Did he whiff more than he hit? Might be a good indicator of his eval skills although when you are in the 30-40 rank in recruiting range you need to long term project prospects as well. Who knows? I'm so glad he's in our conference.
Herms transition class > petermans transition class
Herms > Peterman
Case closed
End of discussion
But let's be real. Herm isn't evaluating shit. Isn't calling plays either. He's there to be the hype man. It's glorious.
Disagree.
You or I can bump this in three years.
Budda
Sydney MF Jones
Greg Gaines
Jo Jo Mac
Dissley Dwag
Keleb Mcgary
Thats six first or second team All Pac performers in a TRANSITION class. EVALUATION is key. We? do it better than most.
Not sure but Virta may have been a late addition in that class as well. Don't twist if not.
Vea was part of that class.[/b]
Then that was one of the best non-Bruce Wayne transition classes ever. I checked and I left out Jaylen Johnson and Dante Pettis. Gardenhire was decent before the weed and Bowman is in the depth. With Vita that is nine high level starters and one depth/rotation guy. That class was ranked 38. Let that sink in. What will Pete do with a class ranked in the top ten? Holy fuck all.
The danger here is set expectations around an outlier. Pete's a great evaluator and developer of talent but he's not THAT good. It's like Seahawks fans thinking Schneider's 2011 and 2012 drafts were going to be normative.
I think Pete will do great with this class. I doubt he'll get as many overachievers as he did in his transition class though.
There is some psychology in play here. I don't want to trigger Dennis but a lower rated guy with a chip on his shoulder might just do more to get better than the guy who has been told all his life that he is a special super star. Like a typical Trojan commit
That's where coaching comes in. A great one will take that 5 star and get him to improve the way an 18 year old should. Like Saban
And hopefully Pete