Shots fired
- Thread starter DerekJohnson
- Start date
You're really putting the Throbber in a tough spot here.
I believe you.
MikeDamone
Well-known poster
Weakest National Champions (Ranked)
1. BYU Cougars football (1984)4
Why #1 (and it’s not close):
Strength of schedule ~80+ range
Beat 6–6 Michigan in the bowl
No elite wins
Won because everyone else lost
This is the gold standard for “technically legit… but come on.”
2. Pittsburgh Panthers football (1976)4
Carried by Tony Dorsett
Weak overall schedule outside 1–2 games
Not a deep or dominant team
3. Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets football (1990 – split title)4
Split title with Colorado
Tied UNC
Needed controversy elsewhere to even be in the convo
4. Colorado Buffaloes football (1990 – split title)
4
The infamous “5th down” game
Also got a controversial call vs Notre Dame
Without those? Probably not champs.5. Oklahoma Sooners football (2000)
4
Great defense, but…
Offense was very average
Won a lot of close, grindy games
Legit—but compared to most champs, not scary.6. LSU Tigers football (2007)
4
2 losses (very rare for a champ)
Chaos year—everyone kept losing
They were the last team standing, not the most dominant7. Florida State Seminoles football (1993)
4
Lost to Notre Dame
Won title anyway due to poll logic
Classic pre-playoff weirdness8. Miami Hurricanes football (2001)
4
Hot take alert
Insanely talented roster BUT:
Weak schedule
Blew out inferior teams
One of the best teams ever, but oddly not battle-tested9. Clemson Tigers football (2016)
4
Needed a last-second play to win
Not dominant week-to-week
Great moment, not dominant season10. Alabama Crimson Tide football (2011)
4
Didn’t even win their division
Got a rematch anyway
Elite team—but controversial path
Key Takeaways#1 BYU 1984 = untouchable “weakest”
Pre-playoff era = tons of weird titles
Modern era champs are generally stronger (playoff filters things)
My blunt summaryWorst champ ever: BYU 1984 (by a mile)
Most “yeah but…” champs: 1990 Colorado / 2007 LSU
Most controversial legit champ: 2011 Alabama
Referring to 2001 Miami as one of the weakest national champions ever is reason 7 zillion and 1 to nuke AI. I'm glad 800 kajillion dollars are being spent on this nonsense.