HH Favorite Rock Album Round 1 (1991- present) - #8 Dookie vs #9 Siamese Dream

[YellowSnow]

 

[GrundleStiltzkin]

Rather easily.

 

[YellowSnow]

Rather easily.

Skrong disagree. Is there a more half brain lyric than "when masturbation's lost its fun, you're fucking lonely"?

Pumpkin songs were always too emo for me.

 

[dnc]

GOAT Pumpkins album has GOAT Pumpkins song with GOAT Pumpkins video

 

[GrundleStiltzkin]

GOAT Pumpkins album has GOAT Pumpkins song with GOAT Pumpkins video

The whole album is outstanding, no filler.

 

[BleachedAnusDawg]

Pumpkins are underrated in the history of rock, IMO.

 

[dnc]

Barn burner here

 

[chuck]

Good battle as it should be.

 

[Mad_Son]

There is no wrong choice here. Remember when rock was awesome?

 

[Gladstone]

Every single track on Dookie[/i] is platinum single worthy.

 

[Tequilla]

Toughest choice I’ve seen so far and I’d argue both under seeded

Dookie has more songs that I’d listen to

Pumpkins has the better songs

Ultimately quality over quantity

 

[alopeciadawg]

Corgan is my favorite.