Who was the first player you ever ripped on? For me it was Damon Huard. I never forgave him for the "pick". Although I wasn't much of a fan of Vince Weathersby either and wanted James to sit him for Lewis.
Another one that hasn't been mentioned yet that needs to be is John Whales. That mother fucker cost UW the Rose Bowl in 1995. I know Lambo is a shit coach but jesus christ kid do your fucking job.
Scott Greenlaw, mainly because my dad would rip him and couldn't believe he was getting playing time at corner.
It's already been said, in college, it all goes back to coaching.